Scathing maternity reviews

A young black mother holds a babyAs you may have seen in recent news coverage, there have been two major reports published into England’s maternity services this summer.

The Amos review, or the Independent Investigation into Maternity and Neo Natal Services in England led by Baroness Amos, which came out on 30 June, examined 12 trusts and concluded that:

“racism and discrimination” are actively “driving inequalities in care” and causing disproportionate harm to minority and deprived women.

The second review, into Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust led by senior midwife Donna Ockenden, The Ockenden Maternity Review, was published a few days earlier, on 24 June.

The Ockenden Review, which evaluated 2,500 family cases between 2012 and 2025, found that 162 stillbirth, neo-natal and maternal deaths were potentially avoidable if appropriate care had been provided.

It also cited that women from ethnic minority as well as deprived backgrounds were particularly affected.

As a result of both reviews, Martha’s Rule is now being extended to all maternity units across England. Martha’s rule gives patients, families, and staff the right to request an independent medical review if they feel a patient’s condition is deteriorating and their concerns are being ignored.

Although the government is due to respond to both reports later this year, the government has already set out a 10 point plan in response.